Tea Blog

One of the highlights of the classic British “cream tea” is its star ingredient—clotted cream. Many people in the United States are unfamiliar with it, and the name itself can be a bit off-putting. (Let’s be honest—“clotted” doesn’t do it any favors!)

So what exactly is clotted cream, and what makes the real version special?

What Clotted Cream Is

Clotted cream is a rich, thick cream with a high fat content—typically 50% or more. It’s traditionally made by gently heating full-cream cow’s milk, then allowing it to cool slowly in shallow pans. As it cools, the cream rises to the surface and forms a thick, slightly golden layer—these are the “clots” that give the cream its name.

This method is most commonly associated with Devon and Cornwall in England. In fact, “Cornish clotted cream” has protected status, meaning it must be produced in Cornwall and meet specific standards, including a minimum fat content of 55%.

What Clotted Cream Is Not

Clotted cream is often confused with other dairy products, but it’s quite different:

• Butter – too firm and not naturally sweet enough
• Whipped cream – too light and airy
• Heavy cream – too thin and pourable

While these can be used as substitutes in a pinch, none truly replicate the texture or richness of clotted cream.

Making Clotted Cream at Home

You can make clotted cream yourself, though it requires patience:

• Start with heavy cream (not ultra-pasteurized if possible)
• Preheat your oven to 180°F
• Pour the cream into an oven-safe dish, about 1–3 inches deep
• Cover and heat for 8–12 hours
• Let it cool, then refrigerate for another 8 hours
• Skim off the thick top layer—that’s your clotted cream

The remaining liquid can still be used in cooking or baking.

What Counts as “Genuine” Clotted Cream?

Many consider Cornish clotted cream—such as that produced by Rodda’s—to be the gold standard. While traveling to England for the real experience would be wonderful, there are several excellent options available in the U.S. that provide a very satisfying substitute.

Final Thoughts

Clotted cream may have an unusual name, but once you taste it, you’ll quickly see why it’s such an essential part of traditional cream tea. Paired with a warm scone and a bit of jam, it creates a rich, indulgent experience that’s hard to match.

See more of A.C. Cargill’s articles here.

© Online Stores, Inc., and The English Tea Store Blog. Unauthorized use is prohibited. Excerpts allowed with proper credit.